UN human rights chief calls on US to ensure that its migration policies ‘respect human dignity’

Category: Top Stories

Listening

Unlocking Word Meanings

Read the following words/expressions found in today’s article.

  1. decry / dɪˈkraɪ / (v.) – to strongly criticize something and say it is bad or wrong, often in public
    Example:

    Many people decried the new rule because it hurt workers. 


  2. scapegoating / ˈskeɪpˌgoʊt ɪŋ / (n.) – the act of blaming one person or one group for a problem, even when they are not really responsible
    Example:

    The teacher explained that scapegoating one student for the group’s mistake was unfair.


  3. xenophobic / ˌzi nə ˈfoʊ bɪk / (adj.) – relating to an idea or behavior that shows fear, dislike, or hatred of people from other countries or cultures
    Example:

    Xenophobic attitudes can harm relationships between different communities.


  4. cornerstone / ˈkɔr nərˌstoʊn / (n.) – the most important part of something; the basic idea, value, or element on which everything else is built or developed
    Example:

    Trust is the cornerstone of a strong friendship.


  5. quell / kwɛl / (v.) – to stop something, especially something strong or negative, such as violence, fear, anger, or protests
    Example:

    The government acted quickly to quell the protests.


Article

Read the text below.

The United Nations human rights chief has called on the United States to ensure that its migration policies and enforcement practices respect human dignity and due process rights.


Volker Turk, in a statement relayed by spokesperson Marta Hurtado, decried the dehumanizing portrayal and harmful treatment of migrants and refugees.


Hurtado said Turk called on leaders “at all levels in the U.S. to halt the use of scapegoating tactics that seeks to distract and divide, and which increase the exposure of migrants and refugees to xenophobic hostility and abuse.”


As US President Donald Trump marks the first year of his second term, the immigration enforcement and removal operation that has been a cornerstone of his domestic and foreign policy agenda is rapidly transforming into something elsea national law enforcement presence with billions upon billions of dollars in new spending from US taxpayers.


The shooting death of Renee Good in Minneapolis showed the alarming reach of the new federalized force, sparking unrelenting protests against the military-style officers seen going door to door to find and detain immigrants.


Amid the outpouring of opposition, Trump revived threats to invoke the Insurrection Act to quell the demonstrations, and the U.S. Army has 1,500 soldiers ready to deploy.


To be sure, illegal crossings into the U.S. at the Mexico border have fallen to historic lows under Trump, a remarkable shift from just a few years ago when President Joe Biden’s Democratic administration allowed millions of people to temporarily enter the U.S. as they adjudicated their claims to stay.


Yet as enforcement moves away from the border, the newly hired army of immigration officers swarming city streets with aggressive tacticsin Los Angeles, Chicago, and elsewhereis something not normally seen in the U.S.


Armed and masked law enforcement officers are being witnessed smashing car windows, yanking people from vehicles, chasing and wrestling others to the ground, and hauling them awayimages playing out in endless loops on TVs and other screens.


This article was provided by The Associated Press.


 


Viewpoint Discussion

Enjoy a discussion with your tutor.

Discussion A

  • The UN human rights chief says U.S. migration policies should respect human dignity and due process. What does “human dignity” mean to you in real-life situations? In your opinion, can strict law enforcement still respect dignity? Why or why not? Discuss.
  • Volker Turk criticized the “dehumanizing portrayal” and “scapegoating tactics” used by political leaders to describe migrants. How can the words used about migrants change how people treat them? Do you think the specific language a leader uses affects the way ordinary citizens treat foreigners in their own neighborhoods? Why do you think so? Discuss.

Discussion B

  • The article describes images of aggressive arrests playing out in “endless loops” on TV and screens across the country. In your opinion, what are the possible impacts of repeated news coverage of police and law enforcement violence to the public? Discuss.
  • Protests followed the death of Renee Good and aggressive enforcement actions. In your opinion, when do protests help bring change, and when do they cause more harm? Why do you say so? How do you think governments should respond to large public demonstrations? Discuss.