A driver faces up to $110,000 in fines for speeding on a Swiss street. But he can afford it

Category: Human Interest

Listening

Unlocking Word Meanings

Read the following words/expressions found in today’s article.

  1. clock / klɒk / (v.) – to measure or record the speed or time at which someone or something is traveling
    Example:

    The runner was clocked running the 100-meter race in 10 seconds.


  2. penal / ˈpiː nəl / (adj.) – relating to laws and punishments for people who break the law
    Example:

    The country’s penal system decides how people are punished when they break the law.


  3. on the hook for (something) / ɒn ðə hʊk fɔr / (idiom) – responsible for paying for something
    Example:

    After the car accident, the driver was on the hook for thousands in repair costs.


  4. tycoon / taɪˈkun / (n.) – a very rich and powerful business person, often owning or controlling a large company
    Example:

    The hotel tycoon is opening his fifth luxury beach resort and hotel.


  5. infraction / ɪnˈfræk ʃən / (n.) – an act of breaking a rule or law
    Example:

    Drivers must pay attention to road signs to avoid any infractions.


Article

Read the text below.

A driver was clocked going 27 kilometers per hour (17 mph) over the speed limit on a street in the Swiss city of Lausanne, and now he’s facing up to 90,000 Swiss francs (over $110,000) in fines as a result. But he can afford it.


Why the eye-popping penalty? Because the speedster, a repeat offender, is one of Switzerland’s wealthiest people, and the Vaud region serves up fines based on factors like income, fortune or general family financial situation.


The Swiss are not alone. Germany, France, Austria and the Nordic countries all issue punishments based on a person’s wealth. The recent fine isn’t even a record in Switzerland. In 2010, a millionaire Ferrari driver got a ticket equal to about $290,000 for speeding in the eastern canton of St. Gallen.


Back then, the Swiss safety group Road Cross said rich drivers had been lightly punished until voters approved a penal law overhaul three years earlier that let judges hand down fines based on personal income and wealth for misdemeanors like speeding and drunk driving.


Under today’s rules, an indigent person might spend a night in jail instead of a fine, while the wealthiest in the rich Alpine country could be on the hook for tens of thousands.


A court in the Swiss canton of Vaud recently ruled that the tycoon must pay 10,000 Swiss francs ($12,300) up front and could be forced to pay the rest—80,000 more—if he’s caught for a similar roadway infraction over the next three years.


Switzerland’s 24 Heures newspaper first reported the case and said the man, who was not identified, was a French citizen listed by the Swiss economic weekly Bilan among the 300 richest people in Switzerland—with a fortune in the hundreds of millions of dollars.


The newspaper reported that he had already been caught for a similar speeding infraction eight years ago, and also paid 10,000 Swiss francs in penalty and faced another 60,000 if another infraction had taken place within the following two years.


This article was provided by The Associated Press.


Viewpoint Discussion

Enjoy a discussion with your tutor.

Discussion A

  • In Switzerland, speeding fines are based on income and wealth, so rich people pay more than poor people. Do you think this system is fair? Why or why not? Discuss.
  • In your opinion, do people in your country strictly follow traffic rules? Why do you say so? Discuss.

Discussion B

  • The speeding driver was caught for the same infraction eight years ago. In your opinion, why do some people keep breaking the same law even after being punished? What does this show about human behavior? Discuss.
  • What do you think is the best way to punish people who break the same traffic laws multiple times (ex. doing community service, taking away the driver’s license)? Discuss.