NYC carriage driver says proposed ban is more about money, real estate, less about animal welfare

Category: Business

Listening

Unlocking Word Meanings

Read the following words/expressions found in today’s article.

  1. wind down / waɪnd daʊn / (phrasal v.) – to gradually stop or finish an activity, business, or event
    Example:

    The research team decided to wind down the experiment after it gave clear and satisfying results.


  2. undulating / ˈʌn dʒəˌleɪ tɪŋ / (adj.) – having a smooth up and down shape or movement, like a wave
    Example:

    The playground was built on undulating ground, so kids could roll balls down the hill.


  3. spook / spuk / (v.) – to become scared
    Example:

    My cat gets easily spooked whenever a loud car passes by.


  4. flaunt / flɔnt / (v.) – to show no respect for rules by ignoring or breaking them on purpose
    Example:

    Tourists sometimes flaunt local customs by refusing to follow dress codes at temples.


  5. pasture / ˈpæs tʃər / (n.) – land covered with grass where animals, like cows, sheep, or horses, eat
    Example:

    The horses ran happily in the green pasture behind the farm.


Article

Read the text below.

For more than 150 years, horse-drawn carriages have been trotting through Manhattan’s Central Park, weathering the arrival of the automobile, years of criticism from animal rights activists and even a mayoral administration that vowed to ban the tourist activity.


But now the influential nonprofit that manages the 843-acre park—and has previously stayed out of the debate—has thrown its support behind a proposal to wind down the industry as early as next summer.


The Central Park Conservancy argued in an August 12 letter to the City Council that horse carriages have an outsized impact on public safety and road infrastructure in the increasingly crowded park.


“Horses are too unpredictable and the roadways are too busy with too many different kinds of users now,” said Elizabeth Smith, the conservancy’s CEO.


Smith noted global cities, including London, Paris and Beijing, have already banned the nostalgic rides, some of them even embracing horseless, electric-powered versions.


Eliminating carriage horses also goes against famed landscape architect Frederick Law Olmsted’s vision for the park, with its hilly paths and undulating roads tailor-made for leisurely carriage rides, argues Christina Hansen, a longtime carriage driver and industry spokesperson.


“We’re seeing the park the way it was meant to be seen,” she said.


Animal rights groups have long complained that horses can get easily spooked on busy city streets, leading to accidents and injuries. They also claim the horses are overworked and live in inadequate stables, and their drivers flaunt city regulations, including leaving behind piles of horse manure. All animals are supposed to be fitted with manure-catching devices.


Carriage horse owners and drivers maintain that their horses enjoy a life of relative ease. Under city regulations, each is inspected by a veterinarian twice a year and must retire by the age of 26.


They work a maximum of nine hours a day and must stop giving rides if it’s above 89°F (32°C) or above 80°F (27°C) with high humidity. They also don’t work if there’s severe weather, and must get at least five weeks’ vacation a year outside city limits with daily access to pasture.


This article was provided by The Associated Press.


Viewpoint Discussion

Enjoy a discussion with your tutor.

Discussion A

  • Carriage rides make New York seem romantic and unique to tourists, but many argue against them. Do you think banning them would hurt the city’s image, or improve it? Why? Discuss.
  • Some cities use electric carriages instead of horses. What do you think about this? What are examples of technology replacing traditions in your country? Was it good or bad? Discuss.

Discussion B

  • Horses share crowded roads with cars, bikes, and people. Do you think it’s fair to use animals for tourism in busy cities? Why or why not? What might be better ways for tourists to enjoy a city without using animals? Discuss.
  • Drivers say the horses have a “good life” with rules about rest, vacation, and retirement. Activists disagree. Do you think animals can ever really live well while working for humans? Why or why not? Discuss.