Medical museum in Philadelphia overhauls policies on human remains to meet modern ethical standards

Category: Human Interest

Listening

Unlocking Word Meanings

Read the following words/expressions found in today’s article.

  1. redraw / riːˈdrɔː / (v.) – to change a plan, rule, or arrangement because things have changed
    Example:

    The city’s old environmental rules were redrawn to protect more green spaces.


  2. specimen / ˈspɛs ə mən / (n.) – something, like an animal or plant, collected as an example of its kind
    Example:

    The museum displays specimens of rare plants from around the world.


  3. anonymize / əˈnɒn əˌmaɪz / (v.) – to remove or hide a person’s name or other personal details so that they cannot be recognized
    Example:

    Journalists often anonymize their sources of information in their articles.


  4. do justice / du ˈdʒʌs tɪs / (idiom) – to show or treat someone/something in the best or most correct and respectful way
    Example:

    The documentary aims to do justice to the lives of local farmers by telling their stories honestly and respectfully.


  5. biographical / ˌbaɪ əˈgræf ɪ kəl / (adj.) – relating to or about a person’s life and experiences
    Example:

    The museum guide shared biographical details about the artist, including where she grew up and how she learned to paint.


Article

Read the text below.

A medical museum in Philadelphia has redrawn its policies on the collection and display of human remains, limiting its acceptance of additional specimens and working to follow “evolving modern medical ethical standards” in how it handles the 6,500 organs, bones and other body parts in its collection.


The College of Physicians of Philadelphia, which owns the Mütter Museum, announced it is restricting the taking of photos and videos of human remains, allowing it only with the museum’s permission. Photography by the public will remain prohibited.


The museum “will allow photography as long as it sort of serves an educational purpose,” said Sara Ray, its director of interpretation and engagement. “But education itself is a pretty broad net that we’re working through.”


The great majority of the remains were collected from about 1840 to about 1940, mostly from Philadelphia, largely body parts and organs that were considered to be helpful in medical education and taken during autopsies or surgery. Such collections were not uncommon among medical societies at a time when specimens were critical to understanding how the body is structured and how it works. But most of those museums are long gone.


The Mütter Museum said it is also working to “de-anonymize” its collection by looking into the personal histories of its human remains to figure out who they are, if possible, and to “do justice” in how it displays them and tells their stories. The goal is to exhibit them in the context of the history of medicine, bodily diversity and the tools and therapies used to treat them.


“The goal is not finding an identity for finding an identity’s sake,” Ray said. “The goal is to find an identity so that we can build a richer biographical profile, through which we can then ask questions about the way that this person navigated the world. And so that’s going to look very different for every single specimen.”


This article was provided by The Associated Press.


Viewpoint Discussion

Enjoy a discussion with your tutor.

Discussion A

  • The museum wants to “de-anonymize” its collection by researching who those people were. How do you think knowing someone’s life story can change the way we view their body after death? Discuss.
  • Human remains helped doctors learn about the body, but now some people feel displaying them in museums may be disrespectful. Do you agree with the opinion of some people that this act may be disrespectful? How can museums keep a balance between imparting knowledge and being respectful? Discuss.

Discussion B

  • Visitors may feel curiosity, discomfort, or even awe when visiting the Mütter Museum. What feelings do you think you might have when looking at human remains in a museum? Why do you think people are often drawn to see unusual or surprising exhibits in museums? Discuss.
  • What museum interests you the most? Why are you interested in this museum? Discuss.