Tokyo court grants legal protection to human voices in AI clone case

Category: Technology/Innovations

Listening

Unlocking Word Meanings

Read the following words/expressions found in today’s article.

  1. landmark / ˈlænd mɑːrk / (adj.) – very important because it is the first or one of the first of its kind
    Example:

    The court made a landmark decision about online privacy.


  2. unauthorized / ˌʌnˈɔːθəraɪzd / (adj.) – done or used without official permission
    Example:

    The company removed the unauthorized video from its website.


  3. clone / kloʊn / (n.) – an exact or very similar copy of a person, thing, or system
    Example:

    The software created a clone of the actor’s voice.


  4. trademark / ˈtreɪd mɑːrk / (n.) – a feature or name that is strongly connected with a person, product, or company
    Example:

    Her bright red hair became a trademark of her public image.


  5. infringement / ɪnˈfrɪndʒ mənt / (n.) – an act of using someone's legal rights or property without permission
    Example:

    The company was accused of copyright infringement.


Article

Read the text below.

A Tokyo court has awarded legal protection to the human voice in a landmark case in which a popular Japanese anime voice actor demanded that TikTok close an account over its unauthorized use of an artificial intelligence clone of his trademark baritone.


The Tokyo District Court’s decision was the first acknowledgment of the right to one’s voice in Japan. The ruling was good news for many anime voice actors at a time when they are increasingly concerned about the use of AI-generated versions of their voices on social media.


The plaintiff, Kenjiro Tsuda, is an actor best known for his “lustrous and deep” voice in starring characters such as Kento Nanami in “Jujutsu Kaisen,” a popular anime series.


In his lawsuit, Tsuda said that the anonymous operator of the TikTok account “Nanami” wrongfully profited by attracting viewers with his voice narrating in more than 180 videos about urban legends and paranormal phenomena, and asked for the material to be deleted.


“The human voice is symbolic of individual personality, just like one’s portrait,” Presiding Judge Aya Takahashi said, according to a court document seen by The Associated Press.


It is appropriate to consider the unauthorized use with an obvious intention to take advantage of the commercial appeal of Tsuda’s voice “an infringement of publicity rights,” Takahashi said.


As of November 2025, the account had more than 200,000 subscribers, with viewers often noting the similarities between the narrator’s voice and Tsuda’s.


The defendant argued that the videos used an AI-generated voice that sounded like Tsuda’s but was not his, and that the videos did not damage the actor’s reputation as a voice actor.


The ruling dismissed Tsuda’s demand that all the videos using his voice be deleted, because the account had already been closed.


The decision comes at a time of growing concern among Japanese voice actors about the AI cloning of their trademark voices in anime.


In 2024, OpenAI announced plans to halt the use of one of its ChatGPT voices after “Her” actor Scarlett Johansson said it sounded “eerily similar” to her own.


Last year, Oscar-winning actors Michael Caine and Matthew McConaughey made deals with voice-cloning company ElevenLabs to allow its AI technology to replicate their voices.


This article was provided by The Associated Press.


Viewpoint Discussion

Enjoy a discussion with your tutor.

Discussion A

  • Kenjiro Tsuda, best known for voicing the character Kento Nanami in “Jujutsu Kaisen,” filed a case over the unauthorized use of his voice using AI. Do you think the availability of AI is a serious problem for voice actors? Why do you say so? Discuss.
  • The ruling was good news for voice actors who are increasingly concerned about AI-generated versions of their voices on social media. Do you think new technology should come with new rules to protect people whose voices are copied? Why or why not? What should those rules try to protect? Discuss.

Discussion B

  • Think about your own voice or another personal feature that people recognize easily. Would you be comfortable allowing technology to copy it if you were paid? Why or why not? What would make you change your mind? Discuss.
  • What other aspects of the creative industry should be protected from AI, such as an actor’s appearance, music, artwork, or writing style? Why? How can the creative industry benefit from these policies? Do you think these policies will keep their art secure and protected? Why or why not? Discuss.