Senators approve withholding their own pay during government shutdowns

Category: Top Stories

Listening

Unlocking Word Meanings

Read the following words/expressions found in today’s article.

  1. impasse / ˈɪm pæs / (n.) – a situation in which progress is impossible because the people or organizations involved cannot agree on something
    Example:

    The trade talks ended in an impasse after both countries refused to reduce their taxes on each other’s goods.


  2. lapse / læps / (n.) – the temporary ending of a legal right, service, or flow of money because a specific rule was not followed or a deadline was missed
    Example:

    Because the council failed to prepare the budget on time, a financial lapse closed the city park.


  3. stipulate / ˈstɪp yəˌleɪt / (v.) – to say or write something clearly and firmly as an official rule, law, or part of an agreement
    Example:

    The document stipulates that the company must pay its workers on the first day of the month.


  4. forfeit / ˈfɔr fɪt / (v.) – to lose or give up something because one made a mistake or broke a rule
    Example:

    If you do not claim your prize within thirty days, you will forfeit it completely.


  5. laborious / ləˈbɔr i əs / (adj.) – needing a lot of time, hard work, and effort to finish
    Example:

    Checking thousands of old office documents one by one is a very laborious process.


Article

Read the text below.

Senators unanimously approved a resolution to withhold their pay during government shutdowns, an attempt to make federal closures financially painful for lawmakers after a string of record-breaking impasses in the past year.


The bipartisan support for the measure comes at a time when federal closures have become longer and more frequent, frustrating lawmakers who say there should be punishment when Congress fails at its most basic legislative duty.


Under the resolution, senators’ pay would be withheld by the Secretary of the Senate whenever a government shutdown affects one or more agencies, and then released once funding is restored. It will take effect the day after the November 3 general election and does not apply to the House.


“Shutting down government should not be our default solution to our refusal to work out our issues and our differences,” said Sen. John Kennedy, the bill’s sponsor, in a floor speech. “This is about putting our money where our mouth is,” said Kennedy.


Two shutdowns in the past year created significant financial hardship for tens of thousands of federal workers, particularly at the Department of Homeland Security. The department reopened last month after a 76-day partial shutdown, the longest agency funding lapse in history.


The Constitution stipulates that lawmakers must be paid, so they have received salaries during shutdowns even as federal workers went without paychecks. When the full government shutdown began in October amid a dispute over health care subsidies, Sen. Lindsey Graham proposed a constitutional amendment to require members to forfeit their paychecks when the government is closed.


“If members of Congress had to forfeit their pay during government shutdowns, there would be fewer shutdowns, and they would end quicker,” Graham said at the time.


Graham said his legislation was the most “constitutionally sound” way to deal with the problem, but the process would have been much more laborious, as three-fourths of states must ratify an amendment.


Lawmakers in previous shutdowns have often pledged to forgo their paychecks while federal workers went unpaid. Senators earn an annual salary of $174,000, but many are independently wealthy.


This article was provided by The Associated Press.


Viewpoint Discussion

Enjoy a discussion with your tutor.

Discussion A

  • In many government shutdowns, thousands of regular federal employees lose their income while elected lawmakers continue to receive their salaries. Do you think it is fair for politicians to keep getting paid when the government they run stops working, or should they face the same financial consequences as regular workers? Why? How do you think lawmakers’ actions would be affected because of this? Discuss.
  • In your country, how do you think the leaders and the public would react to a rule that completely stops politicians’ pay during government shutdowns because of impasses? Would you personally want a law like this in your country? Why or why not? Discuss.

Discussion B

  • Senator John Kennedy mentioned that shutting down the government should not be the “default solution.” Why do you think he believes leaders need to find a different way to agree? Do you think it is ever okay to have government shutdowns? Why or why not? Discuss.
  • In your own experience, is it ever helpful to completely stop working with someone for a short time, or does it usually make the problem worse? Why do you say so? Discuss.