Do you prefer to pay income taxes or sales taxes? Missouri voters will get to choose

Category: Top Stories

Listening

Unlocking Word Meanings

Read the following words/expressions found in today’s article.

  1. abate / əˈbeɪt / (v.) – to decrease or become weaker
    Example:

    The heavy rain abated in the afternoon, so the children were able to play outside.


  2. levy / ˈlɛv i / (v.) – (of a government) to officially demand and collect money, such as a tax, fee, or fine, from a person or organization
    Example:

    The city decided to levy a new tax on plastic bags to protect the environment.


  3. implicitly / ɪmˈplɪs ɪt li / (adv.) – in a way that is understood, even though it is not said or written clearly
    Example:

    She did not say the word ‘yes,’ but she implicitly agreed by giving a thumbs up.


  4. ratification / ˌræt ə fɪˈkeɪ ʃən / (n.) – the act or process of making a deal or agreement final so that everyone must follow it
    Example:

    The ratification of the trade deal between the two countries was completed when both presidents signed the agreement.


  5. sidestep / ˈsaɪdˌstɛp / (v.) – to avoid a difficult job, problem, or rule
    Example:

    The company saved millions of dollars by moving its office to another city, sidestepping the high taxes of the capital.


Article

Read the text below.

It’s not every day—or even every decade—that voters are presented a decision like this: Should the state’s individual income tax be eliminated?


When that question appears on a Missouri ballot later this year, it will mark the first time since the modern income tax began over a century ago that a U.S. state legislature has asked voters whether to eliminate the tax. If they say “yes,” they will also be authorizing a sales tax expansion.


Missouri’s unique proposal caps a five-year tax-cutting binge in states that flourished while governments were flush with cash during the recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic and only recently abated as some Democratic-led states embraced higher tax rates on millionaires. During that time, almost every state made either permanent or temporary reductions to some type of tax, whether on income, sales, property, or gas. And more than half the states that levy income taxes reduced their top tax rate.


Those tax cuts were seldom offset by increasing other types of taxes. But Missouri’s new measure implicitly acknowledges that it’s hard to eliminate an income tax without raising other revenues to keep government running.


Congress gained the power to tax income with the ratification of the 16th Amendment in 1913. Many states adopted their own income taxes over the ensuing years, including Missouri in 1917.


But some states—Florida, Nevada, South Dakota, Texas, and Wyoming—never adopted an individual income tax, instead relying on sales taxes, oil taxes, or other sources. New Hampshire and Tennessee, which taxed income from interest and dividends but not wages, each ended those taxes within the past five years.


Missouri’s proposed constitutional amendment directs the General Assembly to eliminate the individual income tax through gradual reductions based on revenue growth. To spur that along, it gives lawmakers the authority to raise revenues by imposing the sales tax on “any goods and services”—sidestepping a constitutional ban on expanding the sales tax base that voters approved in 2016.


The legislature would have five years to decide which additional sales to tax without needing another vote of the people.


This article was provided by The Associated Press.


Viewpoint Discussion

Enjoy a discussion with your tutor.

Discussion A

  • Missouri is asking voters to decide if they should eliminate the income tax, marking the first time in over a century that a state legislature has asked the people this question. Do you think citizens should have the power to vote on complex laws like taxes, or should these decisions be left only to government leaders? Why? Discuss.
  • What do you think are the advantages and disadvantages of giving the citizens the power to vote on laws? In your opinion, what types of laws should people be allowed to vote on? Discuss.

Discussion B

  • According to the article, Missouri’s plan would allow the state to “raise revenues by imposing the sales tax on any goods and services.” If you had to choose between a system in which the government taxes the money you earn or a system in which they tax every single thing you buy, which would you prefer? Why? Discuss.
  • In your opinion, which is more important for a community: having very low taxes so people have more money, or having higher taxes so the government can provide better public services? Why? Discuss.