Trump Plans to Downsize Some Protected US Sites

Category: Human Interest

Listening

Unlocking Word Meanings

Read the following words/expressions found in today’s article.

  1. scale down / skeɪl daʊn / (phrasal) – to make smaller
    Example:

    We cannot scale down protected lands if we want to save rare plants and animals.


  2. federal / ˈfɛd ər əl / (adj) – relating to a type of government in which power is shared between a central government and governments in individual states or provinces
    Example:

    A federal government seems to be an efficient way to manage a huge country.


  3. spur / spɜr / (v) – to cause something to happen
    Example:

    The government’s mining project spurred criticism from environmentalists.


  4. rumor / ˈru mər / (n) – a story or information that has not been proven but is being passed on to other people
    Example:

    I heard some rumors saying that the president did something bad overseas.


  5. secrecy / ˈsi krə si / (n) – the act of keeping information hidden
    Example:

    Many people criticize some public officials’ secrecy.


Article

Read the text below.

The US government is planning to scale down national monuments to allow for greater economic development.


Last April, US president Donald Trump requested recommendations for monuments that can be downsized from the US Department of the Interior (DOI). Monuments refer to sites of natural and cultural importance, like the Grand Canyon and the Statue of Liberty. US monuments are protected by the American Antiquities Act of 1906, which authorizes presidents to declare any site as a national monument, giving it federal protection. When downsized, protection for some parts of the monument may be revoked, opening them to hunting, fishing, and other activities to boost the economy.


The Interior Secretary submitted a draft of the monuments that may be downsized. The draft included Bears Ears National Monument, which was declared a monument by former president Barack Obama. It is a 1.35 million-acre land that includes sacred Native American soil. The land is also rich in potential oil reserves and uranium, an energy-rich element known for its nuclear capacities. Trump asked the DOI to review the Bear Ears National Monument first.


The news of downsizing monuments delighted those in the energy, mining, and ranching industries. On the other hand, it faced criticism and lawsuit threats from conservation advocates. The government’s plan is also spurring rumors among critics because of the secrecy surrounding it.


The DOI has yet to release the official list of monuments that were reviewed.  This has led some critics to think that the administration might be planning to permit oil drilling, mining, and logging in some of the country’s protected sites.


Viewpoint Discussion

Enjoy a discussion with your tutor.

Discussion A

• Why do you think the US government is keeping the official list secret? Discuss.
• Should a government inform its people about its every move? Why or why not?

Discussion B

• If you were a former president, how would you feel if the new president is undoing policies or declarations you did? Explain.
• In your opinion, to what extent can former leaders influence the decision-making of your country? Discuss.